Arthur M. Scheller III

Art builds trusted relationships with clients by efficiently achieving their objectives.


Arthur Scheller

Art has represented clients for over twenty years in civil and business litigation matters of all kinds, including breach of contract, tort, healthcare, real estate, condemnation, construction, product liability, employment, bankruptcy, class action, and other commercial litigation matters. Art has advised a wide variety of clients, including individuals, business executives, small and midsize businesses, Fortune 500 companies, hospitals, developers, government entities, and nonprofits.

He has tried cases throughout the country as well as overseas, representing clients in numerous domestic and international arbitrations. Additionally, he has substantial appellate experience, participating in appeals in the Seventh Circuit, the Illinois Supreme Court, the Illinois Appellate Courts, and federal and state appellate courts throughout the country.

With a proven track record for obtaining favorable results for his clients, Art builds client loyalty and trusted relationships by developing and executing creative legal strategies that protect his clients and advance their objectives efficiently.

After graduating from law school, Art held a judicial clerkship with the Honorable Justice Allen Hartman of the Illinois Appellate Court.  He then went on to practice law for over eighteen years at one of the nation’s largest law firms (Drinker Biddle & Reath f/k/a Gardner, Carton & Douglas) where he practiced in the Commercial Litigation Group and Products Liability & Mass Tort Practice Groups.

Contact Art: 312.858.6751 |



  • The John Marshall Law School, J.D., magna cum laude, 1993
  • The University of Notre Dame, B.A., cum laude, 1983

Bar and Court Admissions:

  • State Bar of Illinois
  • State Bar of Wisconsin
  • Northern District of Illinois

Representative Matters

Obtained judgment in favor of the nation’s second largest public transportation system, following a two-week trial in a case involving claims for more than $3 million arising out of the construction of five elevated stations and track structures.

Successfully defended a major hospital, its officers, and individual physicians in a case involving breach of contract and tort claims brought by a surgeon whose privileges were terminated following a medical peer review.

Represented a national home builder in obtaining dismissal of an annexation petition following a one-week trial.

Obtained a $2.5 million award of legal fees and expenses on behalf of a landowner, after a local school district abandoned its condemnation of the landowner’s property.

Successfully defended a major medical device manufacturer who was a defendant in over 500 product liability cases pending throughout the United States.  This included cases consolidated in federal court for multi-district litigation.

Served as litigation counsel to a Chapter 7 Trustee in asserting claims for fraud, commodity law, and RICO violations against a futures commission merchant, and negotiated a $10 million settlement for the estate.

Successfully argued appeals in the Illinois Supreme Court and the Illinois Appellate Court on behalf of a major retailer involved in a class action lawsuit which arose out of the retailer’s practice of collecting sales tax on shipping charges for internet purchases.

Successfully defended hospitals in appeals relating to medical peer review, and privileging and credentialing disputes.

Represented national higher education associations as amici curiae (friend of the court) in an appeal involving the privacy rights in student education records.

Successfully defended State of Illinois employees in an appeal involving an alleged breach of fiduciary duties.

Represented clients in various appeals involving Section 1983 claims, eminent domain, property disputes, and attorneys’ fees claims.

Obtained a judgment on behalf of a major medical device manufacturer in an American Arbitration Association hearing involving a $4 million breach of contract case.

Represented a Chicago museum in an American Arbitration Association hearing involving a capital bond financing issue.

Represented a golf course in an international arbitration hearing held in Guangzhou, China involving breach of a construction contract.

Represented a water reclamation district in an American Arbitration Association hearing involving construction of a $48 million wastewater treatment plant.